| President Joseph R. Mergner | -2012- | Chief Adam Poppe |
| President Kenneth Persichetti | -2011- | Chief John I. Alchevsky |
| President Gregory Genovese | -2010- | Chief John I. Alchevsky |
| President Andrew Kubinski | -2009- | Chief John I. Alchevsky |
| President Douglas Velting II | -2008- | Chief John I. Alchevsky |
| President Douglas Velting II | -2007- | Chief Matthew Genovese |
| President Bruce Youmans | -2006- | Chief Matthew Genovese |
| President Douglas Velting II | -2005- | Chief Matthew Genovese |
| President Douglas Velting II | -2004- | Chief Keith Novak |
| President Bruce Youmans | -2003- | Chief James Grande, Jr. |
| President Bruce Youmans | -2002- | Chief Gary Poppe |
| President Bruce Youmans | -2001- | Chief Gary Poppe |
| President Bruce Youmans | -2000- | Chief Wallace W. Jamison |
| President Bruce Youmans | -1999- | Chief Wallace W. Jamison |
| President Bruce Youmans | -1998- | Chief Thomas Singer |
| President Thomas Singer | -1997- | Chief Wallace W. Jamison |
| President Thomas Singer | -1996- | Chief Wallace W. Jamison |
| President Thomas Singer | -1995- | Chief Wallace W. Jamison |
| President Wallace W. Jamison | -1994- | Chief Paul Baumgarten |
| President Bruce W. Youmans | -1993- | Chief Paul Baumgarten |
| President Bruce W. Youmans | -1992- | Chief Paul Baumgarten |
| President Bruce W. Youmans | -1991- | Chief Paul Baumgarten |
| President Charles Anderson | -1990- | Chief Paul Dufour |
| President Charles Anderson | -1989- | Chief Paul Dufour |
| President Charles Anderson | -1988- | Chief Howard Letts |
| President Charles Anderson | -1987- | Chief David VanArsdale |
| President Charles Anderson | -1986- | Chief Howard Letts |
| President Charles Anderson | -1985- | Chief Howard Letts |
| President Charles Anderson | -1984- | Chief John Kebeck |
| President George Edgar | -1983- | Chief William Lodato |
| President Richard Homeny | -1982- | Chief Charlie Childs |
| -1981- | |
| President Gus Stamos | -1980- | Chief David VanArsdale |
| President Ernie Farley | -1979- | Chief David VanArsdale |
| President Ernie Farley | -1978- | Chief George Edgar |
| President Gus Stamos | -1977- | Chief George Edgar |
| President Gerald Samson | -1976- | Chief George Edgar |
| President Gerald Samson | -1975- | Chief Julio Bayron |
| President Gerald Samson | -1974- | Chief James Sloan |
| President Kenneth Wickham | -1973- | Chief Raymond Letts |
| President George Piercy Jr. | -1972- | Chief James Sloan |
| President William Randolph | -1971- | Chief Oliver Youmans |
| President Oliver Youmans | -1970- | Chief James Sloan |
| President Oliver Youmans | -1969- | Chief Richard Sloan |
| President Oliver Youmans | -1968- | Chief Arnold Schenker |
| -1967- | |
| -1966- | |
| -1965- | |
| -1964- | |
| -1963- | |
| -1962- | |
| -1961- | |
| -1960- | |
| -1959- | |
| -1958- | |
| -1957- | |
| -1956- | |
| -1955- | |
| -1954- | |
| -1953- | |
| -1952- | |
| President William Altone | -1951- | Chief Arnold Schanker |
| President William Altone | -1950- | |
| -1949- | |
| President Carl Goetz | -1948- | Chief Arnold Schanker |
| President Steven Lengyll | -1947- | Chief Arnold Schanker |
| President Stanley Switlik | -1946- | Chief Arnold Schanker |
| President Joseph Youmans | -1945- | Chief Arnold Schanker |
| President W.M. Reed, Jr. | -1944- | Chief Arnold Schanker |
| -1943- | |
| -1942- | |
| -1941- | |
| -1940- | |
| -1939- | |
